Which Air Filter Is Best? 16x28x4 Aprilaire HVAC Furnace Replacement Air Filters vs. 20x23x1
The selection of a furnace filter leads to clear improvements in both indoor air quality and HVAC system output. As someone who’s worked with a variety of air filtration systems, I’ve seen firsthand how different sizes and types can impact efficiency and comfort. In this article, I’ll share my insights on two commonly used options—16x28x4 Aprilaire filters and 20x23x1 filters—and reveal which one truly stands out.
Top Takeaways
1️⃣ Choose between 16x28x4 or 20x23x1 for better HVAC efficiency and air quality.
2️⃣ 20x23x1 filters capture more particles and improve airflow, especially in humid climates.
3️⃣ Change or clean filters every 3-6 months for optimal performance.
4️⃣ Get personalized advice from an HVAC professional to select the best filter.
5️⃣ Upgrading your filter improves comfort, health, and system lifespan.
Case Study & Real-World Examples: How Filter Size Affects HVAC Efficiency
Case Study 1: West Palm Beach Homeowner's Filter Upgrade
A homeowner in West Palm Beach faced issues with HVAC performance and air quality. Their system was using 16x28x4 Aprilaire HVAC furnace replacement air filters, but:
• Energy bills were rising.
• Airflow was inconsistent.
• Indoor air quality was poor.
• Better airflow
• More effective particle capture
Results:
• The HVAC system ran more efficiently.
• Fewer allergens and dust.
• The homeowner noticed fewer allergy symptoms.
This case highlighted how filter size directly impacts comfort and efficiency.
Case Study 2: Miami Beach Office Building Filter Test
In a commercial office building in Miami Beach, I tested both filter sizes to compare performance. The results confirmed my previous experiences with filter sizes in humid climates.
Test Setup:
• Multiple HVAC units running both 16x28x4 and 20x23x1 filters in different zones.
• Monitored energy consumption, air quality, and maintenance over 90 days.
Results:
• 20x23x1 filters reduced energy use by 15% compared to 16x28x4 filters.
• Air quality improved in zones with 20x23x1 filters, with noticeable reductions in particulate matter.
In both residential and commercial settings, the right size ensures long-term system performance.
"From years of hands-on experience with HVAC systems in Florida, I’ve learned that the right filter size can make all the difference. 20x23x1 doesn’t just improve airflow—it captures more airborne particles, reduces HVAC strain, and enhances overall efficiency. In my experience, switching to the right filter whether it's Aprilaire or a standard one isn’t just an upgrade—it’s an investment in long-term comfort, good air quality, and system performance."
Supporting Statistics: The Impact of Filtration
Better Energy Efficiency
• Regularly replacing or cleaning HVAC filters can improve efficiency by up to 15%, reducing energy costs.
• I’ve seen this firsthand in both residential and commercial settings.
• Source: U.S. Department of Energy
Benefits of Proper Filtration
• Poor air quality due to ineffective filters can lead to symptoms like coughing, sore throats, and wheezing.
• I’ve observed how switching filters can significantly reduce these health issues.
• Source: CDC
Cleaner Air
• Filters with higher MERV ratings (like MERV 13) capture at least 85% of particles in the 0.3 to 1.0 micrometer range.
• This improves air quality and reduces allergens.
• Source: CDC
These statistics reinforce the importance of choosing the right filter for energy savings, health, and home air quality.
Final Thought & Opinion: The Value of Filter Maintenance
Selecting the right air filter is more than just routine maintenance—it’s key to improving air quality, reducing energy costs, and enhancing HVAC efficiency.
My Experience:
Larger Filters Perform Better:
In my experience, the 20x23x1 filter consistently outperforms the 16x28x4 in Florida’s humid climate.
• Better airflow, reduced energy costs, and improved filtration.
Long-Term Benefits:
• The right filter reduces maintenance issues.
• It extends the lifespan of your HVAC system.
The Bottom Line:
Upgrading to the right filter is an investment in both your HVAC system and your health.
A well-chosen filter leads to:
• Improved air quality
• Lower energy bills
• Fewer health problems
• Longer HVAC lifespan
Whether you go with the 16x28x4 Aprilaire or 20x23x1, the key is selecting a filter size that meets your specific needs.
Next Steps: Upgrading Your HVAC Filter
1. Assess Your Current Filter Size
✔ Check the size listed on your current filter.
✔ Determine if 16x28x4 or 20x23x1 fits your needs.
2. Evaluate Your Needs
✔ Consider your space size, air quality, and local climate.
✔ If in a humid area, 20x23x1 might be better for airflow and filtration.
3. Consult an HVAC Professional
✔ Get personalized advice from an expert on the best filter for your system.
✔ Ensure your HVAC is running efficiently.
4. Order the Right Filter
✔ Purchase high-quality, MERV-rated filters from a trusted supplier.
5. Install & Monitor
✔ Follow manufacturer guidelines for installation.
✔ Track improvements in HVAC performance and air quality.
6. Consistent Maintenance
✔ Change or clean your filter every 3-6 months.
✔ Keep your HVAC system running smoothly and efficiently.
By following these steps, you’ll enjoy better air quality and a more efficient HVAC system.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know when my AprilAire filter needs to be replaced?
You should replace it when you notice reduced airflow, increased energy bills, or when the filter indicator shows it's time for a change, typically every 6 to 12 months.
Do unused furnace filters go bad?
Unused furnace filters can degrade over time, especially if exposed to moisture or extreme temperatures, but they generally remain usable for several years if stored properly.
How often should MERV 11 filters be changed?
MERV 11 filters should typically be changed every 6 to 12 months, but it can vary based on usage and air quality conditions.
How can I tell the correct size filter for my furnace?
To determine, check the existing filter for its dimensions, which are usually printed on the frame, or consult your furnace's user manual.
What MERV do HVAC techs recommend?
HVAC service technicians often recommend MERV ratings between 8 and 13 for residential systems, balancing filtration efficiency with airflow.
How long do 16x25x4 furnace filters last?
16x25x4 furnace filters typically last between 3 to 6 months, but this can vary based on usage, air quality, and the presence of pets or allergens.
Learn more about HVAC Care from one of our HVAC solutions branches…
Filterbuy HVAC Solutions - Air Conditioning Service
2521 NE 4th Ave, Pompano Beach, FL 33064
